Side by side · Fishing Lodges

Newton Cove Resort vs Sointula Lodge

Two fishing lodges side by side from their own published tariffs: Newton Cove Resort from $6,079, Sointula Lodge from $7,035 per person, with seasons, what is and is not in the price, deposit and cancellation terms, and the transfer from the gateway.

How this page is made. Every figure is from the two operators' own published tariffs and booking pages, as recorded in their Ledgers, last read 14 September 2026. The sentences under "Which one" are rules over those figures, not opinion; where an operator publishes nothing, the row says so and the rule stays quiet. Ben has stayed at both.

Newton Cove Resort floating in Esperanza Inlet at sunset

Nootka Sound Newton Cove Resort

Aerial view of Sointula Lodge's dock and two guide boats in a sheltered cove, with the lodge and cabins in the trees behind

North Vancouver Island Sointula Lodge

The record

Side by side

Fact	Newton Cove Resort	Sointula Lodge
From, per person	From $6,079 per person for 3 nights (Fully guided), Summer season (July to September), 2026 tariff	From $7,035 per person for 3 nights (4 Day Fishing Trip), The season (May to October), 2026 tariff
Per night	about $2,026 per person per night, the Fully guided rate divided by its 3 nights	about $2,345 per person per night, the 4 Day Fishing Trip rate divided by its 3 nights
All in, with tax	about $6,383 per person for the shortest stay, with GST at 5%	about $7,387 per person for the shortest stay, with GST at 5%
Stays sold	2 packages of 3 or 4 nights	4 packages of 3 or 4 nights
Priced for	Double, two to a boat; Quad, four to a boat	Double; Single; Triple; Quad
Season	Summer season, July to September	The season, May to October
In the price	A private suite for two with a private washroom, two twins or a king, with plush robes, rainfall showers and deluxe linens Hot breakfast, an artisan boxed lunch, fireside appetisers with select beer and wine, a four-course dinner with select beer and wine, and a 24-hour snack bar 30 hours of guided fishing on a 32-foot North River with a certified guide: two half days and two full days on the 3-night package, three full days on the 4-night Gear, tackle, a boxed lunch aboard, and rain gear if the weather turns Provincially regulated fish processing: filleted, vacuum-packed, flash-frozen and boxed for your departure day Daily housekeeping The guide-boat transfer from Moutcha Bay Resort The Anglers Academy, at no extra charge on any guided boat Kayaks and stand-up paddleboards, the guest lounge, pool and poker tables	Your log cabin, meals (hot breakfast, lunch out on the water or a beach, a four-course dinner from a set menu), and wine, spirits and beer A guided day on the water every day, three to four guests to a boat with a licensed guide, in a 27 ft NorthRiver with an enclosed heated cabin and its own bathroom All fishing gear: rods, reels, tackle, plus Columbia insulated rain jackets, rain pants, rain boots, Mustang inflatable life jackets and children's life jackets On the fishing packages, your catch weighed, filleted, frozen and packed in insulated boxes that check as airline luggage The High Seas Day (bottom fish and salmon off the northern tip of the island) and a day of Great Bear Rainforest fly fishing, both on request, on the fishing packages Beach Bistro lunch of boiled crab on an island one day, the Burger Boat lunch delivered to you on the water another Kayaks, paddleboards, bicycles, the hot tubs and the Finnish sauna, the pool table, the trails and the alpacas Binoculars on the boats
Not in the price	GST at 5% on everything, and PST at 8% on the accommodation share, which the resort does not break out A tidal waters fishing licence with the salmon conservation stamp, bought before you arrive Gratuities: the resort suggests $70 to $100 per guest per day for the guide and 20% of your stay for the shore staff Drinks beyond the select beer and wine at appetisers and dinner Getting to Moutcha Bay Resort, or a seaplane to the dock (the 2025 sheet bundled Seattle flights for about $2,100 more per person; the 2026 sheet gives the schedule without a price) The albacore tuna surcharge on a guided day, when conditions allow in late August and September The single-occupancy upgrade, available but not priced	Tax Getting to the lodge: the flight or drive to Port McNeill and the 15-minute boat ride, or a chartered floatplane; the lodge helps arrange it BC tidal fishing licence, $38.85, printed and in your hand on arrival Tips for staff; the lodge suggests 15% of the trip value per guest A private boat for a party of two, $1,950 The cellar wine list, massages, and the half- and full-day helicopter adventures, priced on request
Deposit	10% of the booking when you reserve, charged to the card on file	33% at booking. Inside 60 days of the trip the whole balance is due at booking.
If you cancel	More than 90 days before arrival: 10% of the booking; the rest refunded 90 days or fewer before arrival: full payment forfeited	More than 90 days out: deposit kept, but fully transferable to another date in the same season; with the lodge's permission, to the next season 90 days or fewer: all funds forfeited; a transfer to another date in the same summer at the lodge's discretion if there is space Moving to the next calendar year: 25% of the deposit paid is applied to a visit the following summer
Getting there	Boat from Gold River (Moutcha Bay Resort, where you park; the resort takes guided guests on by guide boat): an hour by road from Gold River to Moutcha Bay, then a guide boat to Esperanza Inlet, or Air Nootka from Gold River to the dock, in the price. Timing partly our estimate.	Boat from Port McNeill (the Port McNeill dock; the lodge sets arrival and departure times, confirm them before booking travel): 15 minutes by boat to Malcolm Island, not in the price. Timing partly our estimate.
Sleeps	24 guests	18 guests
Region	Nootka Sound, British Columbia	North Vancouver Island, British Columbia
Source	2026 tariff, read 14 September 2026	2026 tariff, read 14 September 2026

"From" is the lowest adult double rate in the newest tariff, per person for the shortest stay sold; the all-in line adds the tax the calculator adds. Anything marked "our estimate" is ours, not the operator's.

Which one

What the record says

On price, Newton Cove Resort is the cheaper way in: from $6,079 per person for 3 nights against $7,035 for 3 nights at Sointula Lodge, both before tax, a gap of $956 a head on the shortest stay each sells.

Sointula Lodge has the longer season, May to October against July to September at Newton Cove Resort, about 26 weeks to 13.

Newton Cove Resort lists more in the price, 9 items to 8; both lists are in the table.

Sointula Lodge is the quicker to reach: 15 minutes by boat to Malcolm Island from Port McNeill. Newton Cove Resort is an hour by road from Gold River to Moutcha Bay, then a guide boat to Esperanza Inlet, or Air Nootka from Gold River to the dock (the timings are partly our estimate).

Sointula Lodge is the smaller place, 18 guests to 24.

Which of those matters is yours to weigh; the pages behind each place have the rest, and the calculators price a stay for your own party.

Newton Cove Resort
The record and the Ledger What a trip costs, all in Request availability
Sointula Lodge
The record and the Ledger What a trip costs, all in Request availability

From the Journal

A story that covers both

From the Journal How to choose a fishing lodge in Canada Read the story

Answered from the record

Which is cheaper, Newton Cove Resort or Sointula Lodge?

What is included at Newton Cove Resort and at Sointula Lodge?

Newton Cove Resort lists 9 things in the price, starting with a private suite for two with a private washroom and hot breakfast, an artisan boxed lunch. Sointula Lodge lists 8, starting with your log cabin, meals and a guided day on the water every day. The full lists, and what each leaves out, are in the table on this page.

How do you get to Newton Cove Resort and to Sointula Lodge?

Newton Cove Resort: Boat from Gold River (Moutcha Bay Resort, where you park; the resort takes guided guests on by guide boat): an hour by road from Gold River to Moutcha Bay, then a guide boat to Esperanza Inlet, or Air Nootka from Gold River to the dock, in the price. Timing partly our estimate. Sointula Lodge: Boat from Port McNeill (the Port McNeill dock; the lodge sets arrival and departure times, confirm them before booking travel): 15 minutes by boat to Malcolm Island, not in the price. Timing partly our estimate.